Category: Ender’s Book

Rank the Series: Ender’s Game Series by Orson Scott Card

Rank the Series

In this feature, I take a look at a series that I’ve either finished or I am caught up through, and rank the books in order of worst to best.  For those readers that aren’t turned off by jumping around (I don’t know how you do it) or for those that just enjoy ranking things, this is for you.

The Series:

Ender’s Game Series by Orson Scott Card.  Note:  This does not include any short stories included in the Ender Univere.

shadow of the giant

13. Shadow of the Giant

Book Four of Ender’s Shadow

Book Eight Chronologically

The penultimate chapter to the Shadow saga, this book continued all of the worst qualities of the Shadow saga (characters that think they know everything, a terrible villain, oversimplified political intrigue) and capped it all off with the most patronizing ending imaginable.  If you are a fan of Petra, I imagine you will hate this book.

xenocide

12. Xenocide

Book Three of Ender’s Saga

Book Twelve Chronologically

After two excellent chapters in the Ender’s Game series, Xenocide feels like a story that was stretched way beyond its original idea into a meandering, endless book of filler.

earth awakens

11. Earth Awakens

Book Three of the First Formic War

Book Three Chronologically

If there’s one consistent with the Ender’s series, it’s that the longer the series goes the more likely diminishing returns are to be expected.  Sadly, the prequel trilogy follows that pattern with this lackluster conclusion.

shadow puppets

10. Shadow Puppets

Book Three of Ender’s Shadow

Book Seven Chronologically

This book is the turning point in the shadow series, as it continues the plot from “Shadow of the Hegemon” but does not feel entirely recycled yet.  The characters are making their way toward pomposity, but they are not yet insufferable.

earth afire

9. Earth Afire

Book Two of the First Formic War

Book Two Chronologically

A fairly average invasion book that continues the plot directly from “Earth Unaware,” but lacks the originality of its predecessor.

shadows in flight

8. Shadows in Flight

Book Five of Ender’s Shadow

Book Ten Chronologically

I might have liked this story better if I didn’t already hate Bean by the end of Shadow of the Giant.  That being said, this book did a nice job of telling a story that felt totally different from anything else in the saga with lower stakes and a more human core.

children of the mind

7. Children of the Mind

Book Four of Ender’s Saga

Book Thirteen Chronologically

This book truthfully had all of the same problems as “Xenocide.”  Namely, it was bloated, padded and heavily featured a storyline (Han Quin-jao’s) that always dragged the book to a halt.  However, this book also benefits from wrapping up the saga of Ender Wiggins, the greatest character in this fictional universe.

ender in exile.jpeg

6. Ender in Exile

Book 1.5 in the Ender Saga

Book Nine Chronologically

From the description and timing of this book, one would expect it to have the same problems with padding and lack of originality, however “Ender in Exile” surprises by again focusing on the human element and providing some nice character growth for Ender on his way to “Speaker for the Dead.”

shadow of the hegemon

5. Shadow of the Hegemon

Book Two of Ender’s Shadow

Book Six Chronologically

Before the Shadow series got bogged down in the political chess match for three books in a row, “Shadow of the Hegemon” was a refreshing new idea set in the Ender universe.  Taking the book out of the space setting and focusing more on the politics of Earth also provided a clever way to develop the rest of Ender’s Jeesh.

earth unaware

4. Earth Unaware

Book One of the First Formic War

Book One Chronologically

The prequel series to Ender’s game got off to a great start with “Earth Unaware,” introducing several memorable new characters and setting the stage for how and why a Battle School would be created.  Card also wisely hints at the revelations about the Buggers true nature that is eventually learned by Ender.

speaker for the dead

3. Speaker for the Dead

Book Two of Ender’s Saga

Book Eleven Chronologically

The sequel to one of the most popular science fiction novels ever, “Speaker for the Dead” amazingly ditches nearly everything that made its predecessor popular and still remains an amazing science fiction standing on its own.  More than any other book in the series, this installment manages to include all of the philosophical statements that Card wants to make but avoid getting bogged down in them.

ender's shadow

2. Ender’s Shadow

Book One of Ender’s Shadow

Book Five Chronologically

Bean was a standout character in “Ender’s Game,” but who could have guessed that a spinoff novel running parallel to “Ender’s Game” from his perspective would be so satisfying?  The only thing that keeps this from being a tougher choice at number one is that a few scenes seem to cheapen Ender’s accomplishments in the first book.

ender's game

1. Ender’s Game

Book One of Ender’s Game

Book Four Chronologically

Was there any doubt what would be number one?  If you’ve read this book and didn’t enjoy it, I’d say consider checking out “Speaker for the Dead,” which is totally different, otherwise this series is likely not for you as the original really is the gold standard for exciting, inventive science fiction action.

Advertisements

“Earth Awakens” (The First Formic War #3) by Orson Scott Card and Aaron Johnston Review

earthw

Earth Awakes 

Author: Orson Scott Card and Aaron Johnston

Release Date: June 2014

The finale to the prequel trilogy features everything you’d expect from this series at this point, which is mostly a negative. The biggest trouble areas continue to be individuals that are smarter than world politics and can manipulate every global situation with just a few persuasive words, as well as the genius younger characters that continue to come up with simple ideas that nobody else ever thinks of.

I actually enjoy the goal of this trilogy, and the actual invasion by the bugs was what I’d hoped to find. The final battle was intense and the stakes about as high as they can be with certain characters guaranteed to survive until later books.

Hopefully any future books in this series will be able to skip the global politics (that have played the same in all of the prequel and Ender’s Shadow books) and focus on the aliens or some new direction.

3-star

“Earth Afire” (The First Formic War #2) by Orson Scott Card Review

earth.jpg
Earth Afire
Author: Orson Scott Card
Release Date: June 2013
I’ve finally figured out this series (about 10 books in). Card writes great first novels (Ender’s Game, Ender’s Shadow, Earth Unaware), but the sequels tend to drop in quality (the one exception being Speaker for the Dead). Most of the various sequels problems relate to Card’s over simplification of global politics, as well as making the child characters in each book act like Ender in terms of intelligence. I didn’t like this book ending on a Cliffhanger, and the solution employed in China seems laughable that the Chinese didn’t come up with it. Still I like the world it takes place in, so I’ll give it a three.
3-star