“Sam and Twitch: The Complete Collection” by Brian Michael Bendis Review

samandtwitch

Sam and Twitch: The Complete Collection

Author: Brian Michael Bendis

Release Date: 2006

I bought the complete Sam and Twitch series on ebay about 12 years ago. The idea of a regular detective story set in the world of superheroes sounded cool and original. For whatever reason, I never got around to reading the series until now, well after I found out about books like Astro City (which I love), Gotham City P.D., and the dozens of other books that come out every year about regular people in superhero universes. I also had no idea when I bought it who Brian Michael Bendis was. Bendis is of course one of the giants in the industry now, although one I’ve always found hit (Alias, All New X-Men) and miss (just about everything else).

My main problem with Bendis is that although the dialogue is snappy, it’s often very one note with each character having the same snarky attitude and witticisms. There’s certainly some of that here, but it’s mainly relegated to all of the periphery characters. Sam (the heavy, opportunistic, vulgar one) and Twitch (the more respectful, family oriented, realistic one) have their differences so that it’s usually pretty simple to remember which ones are talking. (Normally remembering isn’t an issue in comics because a big arrow points to who is talking; in this book there are no speech bubbles, instead there are floating dialogue lines with single lines looping back and forth). With new characters or side characters, it reads more like a one note play centered on Bendis’s humor.

The two main story lines in this first volume are about a South African crime family that has cloaked figures with incredible abilities taking over the organized crime in the city, and a murder mystery where the killer is targeting modern witches. There’s also an interesting one shot told in first person from a killer’s point of view fleeing from the police. Both stories were interesting enough that I was happy to keep reading, but neither was as iconic or interesting as something like the Purple Man from Alias.

The tone of this story was also very adult, definitely not something I’d recommend for young readers. (This is especially true if you read the letters pages in the actual comics.) There is also a great one page cameo for Spawn in one of the issues that I looked for as an image online to include with this review but had no luck finding. As far as Bendis goes, this has more of his strengths than his weaknesses on display and I look forward to checking out the rest of the series.

4-star

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s